But I liked David Rose's stratal tension account very much.
Appraised
|
Appraisal
|
|
Polarity
|
Attitude
|
|
David Rose's stratal tension
account
|
positive
|
affect
|
Notes About Rose's Stratal Tension Account
In the list posting (here), Rose misrepresents lexicogrammar as discourse semantics, and
- mistakes the interpersonal metafunction for the logical (as demonstrated here);
- mistakes the textual metafunction for the experiential (as demonstrated here);
- mis-identifies the Theme of a clause (as demonstrated here);
- speaks of the text when claiming to speak of register and context, and totally misinterprets the context that the text construes and realises (as demonstrated here).
∞
This positive feedback immediately triggered in Rose what Bartlett referred to, in response, as "poorly disguised invective", followed by Rose's positive self-judgements recorded later on this blog.
No comments:
Post a Comment